Months of waiting and anticipation have finally come to an end. We have an answer and an idea of what the future will now hold, and like it or not, change has come.
David Knight has officially signed with BMW to race their new G450X.
That means Knight’s tour of duty here in the U.S. GNCC Tour is over. This is the end of an off-road era with a lot of parallels to the current motocross and supercross scene.
When I first moved to Morgantown hoping to work for Racer X, the magazine crew said the Racer Productions side of the building needed help. I jumped in on the GNCC Series just to make sure I had a job, and soon I was taking photos, running the website, writing stories for Cycle News and things like that.

David Knight is going home.
credit: Jason Hooper
The first weekend after I moved here, I packed my old Isuzu Trooper up and caught the GNCC in Millfield, Ohio. DC told me to call Chris Jonnum at Cycle News (CJ is now the head man over at Road Racer X) and tell him I would be sending a story. Of course, I didn’t really know if I was capable of covering the event, but hey, I needed work. Better yet, about a half hour into the race, I was hooked. The racing was unreal! Dudes passed back and forth, they used strategy and pit stops, and in the end Rodney Smith beat Fred Andrews and Jason Raines by like three seconds. It was one of the best races I had ever seen.
That’s the way those races went for years. I was convinced that the GNCC format was perfect for good racing. Races were too long for someone to just lead all day, so riders would wait, hang out, use strategy, and pass each other back and forth. It was cool.
But then Juha Salminen showed up. That ruined the good racing. Juha was so darned good that he actually could lead all day. He was so smooth, he hardly used any energy, so he could pin it off of the start and still hold the pack off in the third hour. By the time he was done here in 2006, people were calling Juha the GOAT off-road. He was surely the Ricky Carmichael of the woods.
Juha left on top, winning two GNCC Titles for KTM and then moving back to Europe. Knight came in to replace him for the 2007 season. Like James Stewart to Carmichael, Knight was the obvious heir apparent to Juha’s kingdom. Like Stewart, Knight found it really, really hard to match that standard. For years, people wondered if James was better than Ricky. When they finally raced, Ricky kept winning championships. Stewart tried hard, but in the end, Ricky emerged clearly as the GOAT .

Juha Salminen
credit: Tony Scavo
Knight and Juha never really faced off. They raced at a GNCC in Ohio in October ’06, but both struggled testing new bikes for 2007, so it didn’t really prove anything. They also met at a few odd events, like the Erzburg Rodeo that you see on the Nitro Circus videos. There, Knight’s long legs gave him an advantage. This summer Knight raced a World Enduro Event in Wales. Juha won that one, but Knight hadn’t raced an Enduro in two years while Juha had been campaigning them full-time. Head to head for a full season, both in their prime? Never happened.
The only way Knight could compete with the legend of Juha was to race against the ghost of Juha. He did a pretty good job. Knight has enough speed to check out on the GNCC pack and turn the races into three-hour snoozers, just like Juha did, or just like Ricky and James did to a 30-minute plus two moto.
The Nationals have never been dominated the way they have been dominated by RC and Bubba. The GNCCs have never been dominated the way they were by Salminen and Knight.
But since Juha and Knighter never really got a chance to race, the question I get asked most is “So, who is better, Juha or Knight?”
For the answer, you can really look to RC and Bubba for guidance. James Stewart can do incredible things on a motorcycle. His talent and skills are off the charts, next level and untouchable. On his best day, no one can stop him, and we’ve seen that proven countless times.
Knight is the same way. His size leads many to think he’s a brute, but in reality he’s more technically precise and skilled than his competition. If size alone made you fast, factories would be looking for the next Shaq. Knight is amazing because he couples incredible skills with his size, so you’ve got a freak of nature in the motorcycle sense—kind of like Randy Moss coming into the NFL with speed, balance and height all in the same package. There’s a reason Travis Pastrana calls Knight “the behemoth ballerina.”
Every once in awhile Stewart goes out and does something that makes you shake your head, because you know he’s the only one on earth that can make a 450cc motorcycle do it. Knight does the same in the woods.
But they don’t hand out championships for dropped jaws. Carmichael may not have invented the scrub, but you can’t argue his win record. Or his loss record. Ricky didn’t just win races, he didn’t lose them. He didn’t get hurt. Didn’t crash out. Didn’t break his bike. Didn’t get tired. Didn’t fall in the first turn. Didn’t even get bad starts. Ricky was a machine that could avoid the pitfalls that plague every racer in every racing sport, from beginner to pro.
Juha is the machine of off-road. His level of preparedness extended beyond just training hard. He lived right next to the KTM shop in Ohio, so he was always involved in every last detail of prep. He never came to a race and put himself in a bad situation. Even when he was brand new to the series, he rode with an air of experience. A lot of bad situations can arise in three hours, but Juha never got in them. Here’s a crazy fact: Two weeks ago, Salminen got married. He was engaged when he lived here, but he never had his fiancé come and visit. Juha said racing was his job, and he needed to take care of his job first.
In contrast, Knight commuted back and forth between the Isle of Man and here. He tried different bikes in different races. He raced EnduroCrosses and the Erzburg race and local races back home between GNCCs. Once, he raced an EnduroCross in Denver on a Saturday and a GNCC in North Carolina on Sunday. Knight has fun with what he does, and with his talent and skills, he should. You’re only good once, so you might as well take advantage.
But occasionally he made mistakes. Bad starts, mis-reading pit boards, whatever, the big man made a few errors, and he threw away a couple of wins. Some of it was just bad luck. But Juha never had bad luck. Neither did RC. I don’t think that’s a coincidence. Was Knight ever not the fastest guy in the race? Not really. But Stewart had always been fast, too. Mistakes can bite you.
So, like Stewart and Carmichael, I’ll take the evidence I saw from the last four years and sum up Juha versus Knighter like this: On their best day, Knight wins. But over the championship long haul, I’ll put my money on Juha.
Now they’ll both be racing in Europe next year. Sounds like the good racing is about to return to the GNCCs!